Yesterday on the Denver criminal defense lawyer blog, I took a look at the exclusionary rule. The exclusionary rule says that if a cop does a search without a warrant and probable cause, the evidence can't be used against you in court. In that post, I mentioned that there are a lot of exceptions which mean the evidence can be used against you even if there is not a warrant and probable cause. I'm going to start with the exception that drives Denver criminal defense lawyers like me nuts: the consent exception.
Basically, the rule with consent is that if you consent to a search of your belongings, your Denver criminal defense lawyer can't come back later and suppress the evidence. This is a problem for defendants in a lot of cases, because cops are really good at getting you to consent. They'll tell you it'll go quicker if you let them have a look. They'll also imply that you don't really have a choice, they can do it the easy way or the hard way. That part is technically true, although if they do it the "hard way" you reserve your right to challenge the search later and possibly get crucial evidence thrown out of the case against you. Basically, the police will not be clear on the importance of waiving your fourth amendment rights. And make no mistake: when you consent to a search, you are waiving your fourth amendment rights.
Adding to this is a problem of basic human psychology. Many suspects think that only guilty people will invoke their rights, or refuse consent. They think if the cops hear "no," they will look more guilty, and things will go worse. However, if you've been pulled over, or stopped on the sidewalk or whatever, you already look pretty guilty in the eyes of law enforcement. Giving in to a request for a consent search isn't going to change that. It's just sacrificing one of your crucial weapons in the possible case against you down the road. Once you consent to the search, you are also telling the police that it's OK to bring anything they find into the case against you. A clear, vocal, renunciation of consent puts the burden of showing probable cause and possibly a warrant squarely on the shoulders of the prosecution. Do you really want to do the prosecutor's work for him?
Showing posts with label denver defense attorney. Show all posts
Showing posts with label denver defense attorney. Show all posts
Sunday, August 28, 2011
Thursday, July 28, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / probable cause
In light of last week's discussion of reasonable doubt, I thought it might be useful to talk about some other burdens of proof. Reasonable doubt is obviously the most important tool for Denver criminal defense lawyers, because it can singlehandedly get the defendant acquitted without anything else. A defendant can simply argue that the prosecution did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt. If the jury agrees, the defendant is acquitted. That said there are several other burdens of proof (or levels to which the lawyer must prove his case) that are crucial during a criminal trial.
Probably the most important is probable cause. This is the level of proof the state must meet in proving evidence is admissible. It applies for both out of court testimony and evidence found through searches. This is because the Fourth Amendment requires officers have probable cause to believe a crime has been committed and that the search will unveil evidence of the crime (the Constitution doesn't actually say that, but the courts have read that into the amendment). So if your Denver criminal defense attorney can show that either of these things did not happen, the fruits of the search are excluded. That can be so fatal to the prosecution's case the evidence is simply excluded.
In the case of a "seizure" or an arrest, the prosecution has to show that either they had probable cause to believe a felony took place, or that they directly saw a misdemeanor. Either of these is good enough to justify an arrest. If these are not present, any answers you give during interrogation after arrest, or things found during searches at your arrest can't be put into evidence at trial.
So what in the world is probable cause anyway? Basically there is no great way to easily define it. It really is evidence that gives one pretty strong reason to suspect, though that's probably not terribly helpful either. The way lawyers look at it is this: there are a million cases where the Supreme Court and lower courts have looked at evidence and testimony and said "yes" or "no" to the probable cause determination. Your Denver criminal defense attorney knows these cases and can put together the strongest motion possible to exclude the evidence against you.
Probably the most important is probable cause. This is the level of proof the state must meet in proving evidence is admissible. It applies for both out of court testimony and evidence found through searches. This is because the Fourth Amendment requires officers have probable cause to believe a crime has been committed and that the search will unveil evidence of the crime (the Constitution doesn't actually say that, but the courts have read that into the amendment). So if your Denver criminal defense attorney can show that either of these things did not happen, the fruits of the search are excluded. That can be so fatal to the prosecution's case the evidence is simply excluded.
In the case of a "seizure" or an arrest, the prosecution has to show that either they had probable cause to believe a felony took place, or that they directly saw a misdemeanor. Either of these is good enough to justify an arrest. If these are not present, any answers you give during interrogation after arrest, or things found during searches at your arrest can't be put into evidence at trial.
So what in the world is probable cause anyway? Basically there is no great way to easily define it. It really is evidence that gives one pretty strong reason to suspect, though that's probably not terribly helpful either. The way lawyers look at it is this: there are a million cases where the Supreme Court and lower courts have looked at evidence and testimony and said "yes" or "no" to the probable cause determination. Your Denver criminal defense attorney knows these cases and can put together the strongest motion possible to exclude the evidence against you.
Thursday, July 21, 2011
Denver criminal lawyer / the role of the Supreme Court
On the Denver criminal defense lawyer blog, I've been talking quite a bit about appeals. As you may have noticed, a lot of appeals end up with a failed petition to the Colorado Supreme Court and the U.S. Supreme Court. In most cases, the Supreme Court won't even hear the case. So what's it even for?
Basically the Supreme Court is more of a political institution than a court. Although the common law evolved out of hundreds of cases being heard, decided and recorded, and the Supreme Court is in the mold of a common law court, the number of cases in the entire United States makes it impossible for them to hear even a fraction of them. So they basically just pick the politically important ones--ones where the court wants to change the law in some significant way and where the facts fit their idea of a good case to change course. In fact, if you do get heard by the U.S. Supreme Court after losing at the circuit or State Supreme Court level, there's a good chance you'll win: a known saying among Denver criminal defense lawyers is that the Supreme Court hears cases to overturn them, not to affirm.
However the fraction of cases, and specifically the fraction of criminal law cases, pales to the number of cases in the United States. There are hundreds of thousands of criminal cases in U.S. state and federal courts. The Supreme Court only hears a little over one hundred each year. Of those, many are from maritime law (over which the Supreme Court has significant jurisdiction). Others are cases where states are suing other states, federal civil cases, and cases where an executive officer is charged. That means probably less than 20 criminal cases make it all the way to Washington each year. And some of those are federal! So the chances of a regular old Denver criminal defense lawyer and his client getting a day in front of the nation's high court are pretty much nothing. Because the Supreme Court is a political body and really hears cases to help in governing the country and interpreting the constitution, not to correct errors in state courts.
Basically the Supreme Court is more of a political institution than a court. Although the common law evolved out of hundreds of cases being heard, decided and recorded, and the Supreme Court is in the mold of a common law court, the number of cases in the entire United States makes it impossible for them to hear even a fraction of them. So they basically just pick the politically important ones--ones where the court wants to change the law in some significant way and where the facts fit their idea of a good case to change course. In fact, if you do get heard by the U.S. Supreme Court after losing at the circuit or State Supreme Court level, there's a good chance you'll win: a known saying among Denver criminal defense lawyers is that the Supreme Court hears cases to overturn them, not to affirm.
However the fraction of cases, and specifically the fraction of criminal law cases, pales to the number of cases in the United States. There are hundreds of thousands of criminal cases in U.S. state and federal courts. The Supreme Court only hears a little over one hundred each year. Of those, many are from maritime law (over which the Supreme Court has significant jurisdiction). Others are cases where states are suing other states, federal civil cases, and cases where an executive officer is charged. That means probably less than 20 criminal cases make it all the way to Washington each year. And some of those are federal! So the chances of a regular old Denver criminal defense lawyer and his client getting a day in front of the nation's high court are pretty much nothing. Because the Supreme Court is a political body and really hears cases to help in governing the country and interpreting the constitution, not to correct errors in state courts.
Wednesday, July 20, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / federal habeas corpus
So this has been sort of a series of posts on the Denver criminal defense lawyer blog. First I talked about post-conviction relief, then direct appeals, then petitioning for review from the Supreme Courts of both Colorado and the United States. If you were scoring at home, this we've already had seven courts have the case under their umbrella. The trial court initially held the jury trial. The state court of appeals, the state supreme court, and possibly the United States Supreme Court (though probably not) all looked at it on direct appeal. After that, there was a post-conviction relief trial, which can also be appealed all the way to the state supreme court. Although it probably has been five years since the initial conviction as the case worked its way through the courts, the defendant (I'll still call him the defendant even though he was convicted long ago for sake of clarity) has one more remedy: federal habeas corpus.
Under 28 U.S.C. section 2254, a prisoner convicted of a crime in state court may challenge his detention in the United States district court where he is incarcerated. Although most folks think this just another appeal, there are a couple of distinctions and requirements that make habeas corpus a bit different. First, the defendant has to be incarcerated. Habeas corpus is a remedy for imprisonment, not anything else, so if you are looking to get an expungement, hire a lawyer for that and go to state court. Second, the claims brought in federal court must have also been brought in state court at some time or another. That means if your Denver criminal defense lawyer didn't object to something, then that wasn't raised at post-conviction relief in the state court, the federal court will decline to hear it. Finally, and this should make sense because it's federal court, the claims have to arise under the United States Constitution. State law claims can be raised in state post-conviction or state habeas.
If you meet all these requirements, it's possible to get the conviction thrown out in federal court. Of course, the defendant still needs to actually have a good case and needs a lawyer who will argue it well. Most of the mistakes are caught on direct appeal and at post-conviction, but occasionally the state and the courts really, really screw up, or do something really bad. The hardest part about trying to win at habeas is that since the defendant has already been proven guilty. The defendant now has the burden of proving the state or his lawyer messed up by a preponderance of the evidence. Habeas is hard to win, though in the right case it can be a very powerful weapon.
Stay tuned to the Denver criminal defense lawyer blog for a series of posts on the federal process.
Under 28 U.S.C. section 2254, a prisoner convicted of a crime in state court may challenge his detention in the United States district court where he is incarcerated. Although most folks think this just another appeal, there are a couple of distinctions and requirements that make habeas corpus a bit different. First, the defendant has to be incarcerated. Habeas corpus is a remedy for imprisonment, not anything else, so if you are looking to get an expungement, hire a lawyer for that and go to state court. Second, the claims brought in federal court must have also been brought in state court at some time or another. That means if your Denver criminal defense lawyer didn't object to something, then that wasn't raised at post-conviction relief in the state court, the federal court will decline to hear it. Finally, and this should make sense because it's federal court, the claims have to arise under the United States Constitution. State law claims can be raised in state post-conviction or state habeas.
If you meet all these requirements, it's possible to get the conviction thrown out in federal court. Of course, the defendant still needs to actually have a good case and needs a lawyer who will argue it well. Most of the mistakes are caught on direct appeal and at post-conviction, but occasionally the state and the courts really, really screw up, or do something really bad. The hardest part about trying to win at habeas is that since the defendant has already been proven guilty. The defendant now has the burden of proving the state or his lawyer messed up by a preponderance of the evidence. Habeas is hard to win, though in the right case it can be a very powerful weapon.
Stay tuned to the Denver criminal defense lawyer blog for a series of posts on the federal process.
Tuesday, July 19, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / appealing to the Supreme Court
If the direct appeal is successful, typically the appellant (fancy word for convicted person who appealed his conviction), has a few remaining opportunities to attempt to have the conviction set aside. The first option is to petition the Colorado Supreme Court for review of the appellate court's dismissal. The defendant and his Denver criminal defense attorney can argue that the trial and appellate courts incorrectly applied the federal or state constitutions, or ignored Colorado statutes. However, the Supreme Court need not even hear the case in the first place. That's because only the initial appeal to the Court of Appeals is considered an "appeal of right." The remaining ones are a privilege. As such, the Colorado defense attorney charged with going to the Supreme Court can not skip straight to briefing the case. First, he must write a petition (a one or two page argument) telling the Colorado Supreme Court why it should even take briefs on the case. Generally the Court is looking to make a legal statement, not simply reverse the error. So the best lawyers will attempt to make an argument that the individual case represents a good opportunity for the Court to either change the law or make a statement. Of course, the odds of even having the case heard are extraordinarily slim.
However, if the court does decide to hear the case, then the real work begins. The briefing process described in the previous post happens all over again. Since the Court has already decided the case was important enough to hear, they are almost certain to have oral arguments, again as described in the post on direct appeals. If the Colorado Supreme Court does decide to hear the case, the chances of getting the appeals court's decision reversed are fairly good. However, this happens in a miniscule fraction of the cases. For all intents and purposes, the defendant should simply begin planning for the post-conviction relief process. But going through the formalities of the appeal to the Supreme Court is crucial for reasons I'll detail in the next post about habeas corpus.
After the petition to the State Supreme Court is (in all likelihood) turned down, the defendant has one last option: appeal to the United States Supreme Court. Appeals from the state supreme court do not go through the federal process with the district and circuit courts. That's because those courts only have jurisdiction over federal law cases and certain civil law cases. A petitioner from a state must go directly to the U.S. Supreme Court with an argument for why his constitutional rights were violated. Of course, this is exceedingly unlikely, since the Court hears only about 100 cases per year from the entire United States, including federal law cases, certain civil cases where people are from different states, and direct appeal cases. As I said, after the initial appeal, it is probably time to start planning for post-conviction relief.
However, if the court does decide to hear the case, then the real work begins. The briefing process described in the previous post happens all over again. Since the Court has already decided the case was important enough to hear, they are almost certain to have oral arguments, again as described in the post on direct appeals. If the Colorado Supreme Court does decide to hear the case, the chances of getting the appeals court's decision reversed are fairly good. However, this happens in a miniscule fraction of the cases. For all intents and purposes, the defendant should simply begin planning for the post-conviction relief process. But going through the formalities of the appeal to the Supreme Court is crucial for reasons I'll detail in the next post about habeas corpus.
After the petition to the State Supreme Court is (in all likelihood) turned down, the defendant has one last option: appeal to the United States Supreme Court. Appeals from the state supreme court do not go through the federal process with the district and circuit courts. That's because those courts only have jurisdiction over federal law cases and certain civil law cases. A petitioner from a state must go directly to the U.S. Supreme Court with an argument for why his constitutional rights were violated. Of course, this is exceedingly unlikely, since the Court hears only about 100 cases per year from the entire United States, including federal law cases, certain civil cases where people are from different states, and direct appeal cases. As I said, after the initial appeal, it is probably time to start planning for post-conviction relief.
Monday, July 18, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / direct appeals
Before someone convicted of a crime can file an action for post-conviction relief and argue that his Denver criminal defense lawyer performed inadequately, he must go through the direct appeals process. This means hiring a lawyer to review the original case and find the issues that are appealable. First things first, though, the defendant must decide relatively quickly whether to file an appeal. The time limit for filing a notice of appeal is generally just 30 days. Once the defendant decides to appeal, hires a Colorado appeals attorney, and files the notice of appeal, the real work starts. First, the most important aspect of appeals, unlike the initial trial, is written advocacy. The judges do not even hear argument on the majority of cases, simply deciding them on the basis of the filings made by the parties. So the first step for the defendant and his lawyer is to review the case and look for places where the trial court may have made a mistake. Although there may be a large number of these, the defendant should focus the argument on just a few arguments, and make those arguments highly persuasive. A brief that stretches too thin and is not selective in its arguments is much less likely to succeed.
The attorney will then file a brief outlining the points where the trial court erred. The state then files a response brief with the court. The defendant hand his or her attorney may ask for the chance to bring a rebuttal, where they address new points that were brought up in the state's brief. At this point, the court may decide to decide the case or schedule it for oral argument. Oral argument only takes place where the court sees the case as exceptionally important or wants further clarification as to some of the issues in the case. Nonetheless, it is crucial that a good appellate attorney be able to both read and speak clearly to be at his most persuasive.
The attorney will then file a brief outlining the points where the trial court erred. The state then files a response brief with the court. The defendant hand his or her attorney may ask for the chance to bring a rebuttal, where they address new points that were brought up in the state's brief. At this point, the court may decide to decide the case or schedule it for oral argument. Oral argument only takes place where the court sees the case as exceptionally important or wants further clarification as to some of the issues in the case. Nonetheless, it is crucial that a good appellate attorney be able to both read and speak clearly to be at his most persuasive.
Friday, July 15, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / what is post-conviction relief?
As a Denver criminal defense lawyer, one question I hear a lot is what sort of options a person has after being convicted of a crime. Although the vast majority of those who are convicted of crimes will end of just serving out their sentence and being released, paroled, or fined, the State of Colorado does offer a few options for those who want to challenge their convictions to the end. The first option is direct appeal, which I will talk about in a later post. After defeat on direct appeal, the convicted person may bring an action in Colorado District Court for post-conviction relief. Generally, this action will cover anything that he was not able to raise on appeal, including violations of rights under the Colorado and United States Constitutions. Post-conviction actions take two main forms.
By far the most common form of post-conviction relief action is a suit claiming the original Denver criminal defense lawyer performed ineffectively. Many times the trial attorney can make it impossible to properly appeal a case because he didn't object on the record. That means the Court of Appeals can't review that potential mistake by the trial court. Or it's also possible the Denver criminal defense lawyer didn't do a good job investigating the case. The standard in these cases is that the lawyer's conduct must fall below a reasonable standard of professional conduct. If the attorney had limited resources and made a reasonable decision on what to investigate, the court won't grant relief. Additionally, the defendant must prove at post-conviction that absent the attorney's mistake, there would have been a reasonable probability of a not-guilty verdict. So if the potentially beneficial avenue of investigation would not have changed the outcome, no relief is available.
The other common form of post-conviction relief action is against the prosecutor for misconduct. Generally this relates to evidence that was not disclosed during the discovery phase of the investigation. Since non-disclosure of relevant evidence is very serious, the burden here isn't quite as high. However, it also doesn't happen very much. Prosecutors know their convictions can be thrown out if they don't disclose, so they are scrupulous.
Next post will be about direct appeals. Stay tuned.
By far the most common form of post-conviction relief action is a suit claiming the original Denver criminal defense lawyer performed ineffectively. Many times the trial attorney can make it impossible to properly appeal a case because he didn't object on the record. That means the Court of Appeals can't review that potential mistake by the trial court. Or it's also possible the Denver criminal defense lawyer didn't do a good job investigating the case. The standard in these cases is that the lawyer's conduct must fall below a reasonable standard of professional conduct. If the attorney had limited resources and made a reasonable decision on what to investigate, the court won't grant relief. Additionally, the defendant must prove at post-conviction that absent the attorney's mistake, there would have been a reasonable probability of a not-guilty verdict. So if the potentially beneficial avenue of investigation would not have changed the outcome, no relief is available.
The other common form of post-conviction relief action is against the prosecutor for misconduct. Generally this relates to evidence that was not disclosed during the discovery phase of the investigation. Since non-disclosure of relevant evidence is very serious, the burden here isn't quite as high. However, it also doesn't happen very much. Prosecutors know their convictions can be thrown out if they don't disclose, so they are scrupulous.
Next post will be about direct appeals. Stay tuned.
Wednesday, June 15, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / yes prison really is that bad
Occasionally pop culture kind of makes prison out to be a lark. There's George Michael Bluth in "Arrested Development" playing softball in prison and chilling with arsonists. There's Avon Barksdale playing softball and running a drug operation for a few years after he gets busted. There's also the occasional story about some old guy with no money intentionally committing a crime so he'll have a warm place to sleep in the cold winter. However, as a Denver criminal defense lawyer, I feel I need to point out to my clients (if they don't understand already) that prison is really brutal. Here is a case in point:
Prosecutors said that the four inmate assailants used their fists, feet and padlocks attached to belts to beat Zuniga-Garcia to death in his cell, according to the Denver Post. The attackers, Jose Augustin Pluma, Juan Martin Ruelas, Mark Rosalez and Justin Hernandez are being indicted with second-degree murder, conspiracy and possession of contraband in prison.Now obviously only the those who are convicted of the most serious crimes will do time in the Supermax Prison in Florence where this murder took place. Most Denver criminal defense lawyers will not try a federal case in their whole careers, let alone a case where the defendant is considered one of the most dangerous in the entire federal system. However, concerns about the living conditions across the federal prison system are rampant, from health care in California (which was recently ordered to reorganize its prisons and decrease the population by 30,000 inmates) to the concerns about sexual assault across the entire American penal system. All in all, even a very short prison sentence is probably worse for the average criminal defendant than a suspended sentence with a variety of service requirements and the like. If your Denver criminal defense lawyer can negotiate a non-penal sentence, that is a good thing.
Tuesday, June 14, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / how to handle a BAC test
As stated earlier on this blog, if you decline a blood alcohol test, you could face pretty serious administrative and criminal sanctions. By completely refusing the breathalyzer, you give your Denver criminal defense lawyer significantly less to work with. However, there are a few things you can do to handle the tests properly and minimize the damage.
First, remember the hand-held test the police may attempt to administer is completely optional. This is not covered by the implied consent doctrine, so refusing to blow right away cannot get you in trouble. That's because the hand-held units are considered fairly inaccurate, and aren't admissible in court to prove your blood alcohol content. As such, the only thing that can come of submitting to the roadside tests is additional evidence allowing law enforcement to conduct more detailed investigation, including bringing you back to the station for a more accurate breath or blood test. Remember, a large portion of your Denver criminal defense lawyer's case is going to rely on proving the stop and arrest were illegal. The less law enforcement can get on the scene, the more likely the stop can be shown to be illegal.
Second, in Colorado, those suspected of DUI have the right to a blood test. A breath test is easier and cheaper for law enforcement, so you probably won't be told about this. However, that's not your business. The blood test is much more accurate and slightly harder to obtain. As such, it increases your chances of getting the right result.
Finally, call a Denver criminal defense attorney and exercise your right to an attorney as soon as possible. Even if you can't remember all these rights, an attorney has been through many of these cases and can help guide you through your dealings with law enforcement as well as the rest of the case.
First, remember the hand-held test the police may attempt to administer is completely optional. This is not covered by the implied consent doctrine, so refusing to blow right away cannot get you in trouble. That's because the hand-held units are considered fairly inaccurate, and aren't admissible in court to prove your blood alcohol content. As such, the only thing that can come of submitting to the roadside tests is additional evidence allowing law enforcement to conduct more detailed investigation, including bringing you back to the station for a more accurate breath or blood test. Remember, a large portion of your Denver criminal defense lawyer's case is going to rely on proving the stop and arrest were illegal. The less law enforcement can get on the scene, the more likely the stop can be shown to be illegal.
Second, in Colorado, those suspected of DUI have the right to a blood test. A breath test is easier and cheaper for law enforcement, so you probably won't be told about this. However, that's not your business. The blood test is much more accurate and slightly harder to obtain. As such, it increases your chances of getting the right result.
Finally, call a Denver criminal defense attorney and exercise your right to an attorney as soon as possible. Even if you can't remember all these rights, an attorney has been through many of these cases and can help guide you through your dealings with law enforcement as well as the rest of the case.
Thursday, June 9, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / what about a no blow?
Most Denver criminal defense attorneys will advise you not to cooperate with the police on the scene and instead ask for your Denver DUI lawyer immediately. That's because most of the things police officers will ask you to do, such as roadside sobriety tests and answering questions are totally optional. You don't have to do them, and it can't be used as evidence against you in court if you decline to cooperate. There is one exception: the blood alcohol test. Although the blood alcohol test is technically optional, if you decline to take it, the penalty is actually more severe than blowing an illegal level.
That's because of a doctrine called "implied consent." The theory goes that by possessing a driver's license, you have consented to reasonable measures to keep the road safe. Although this may sound somewhat like hooey (doesn't everybody have to drive?) the Supreme Court permits it under the constitution. As such, although you do have the right to decline a sobriety test, you'll be punished for doing so. A "no-blow" can result in you license being suspended for up to a year, along with a stint in jail. As such, while it's best to not answer an officer's questions in the field, and smart not to subject yourself to field sobriety tests, and you should definitely call a Denver criminal defense lawyer as soon as you think you might be in trouble for a DUI, one thing you probably won't be able to ultimately avoid is taking some kind of blood alcohol test. I will have more commentary on this in a later post, but for now just know that a Denver DUI lawyer can help make sure the blood alcohol test does as little damage to your case as possible, while protecting your rights throughout the process, so call one as soon as possible.
That's because of a doctrine called "implied consent." The theory goes that by possessing a driver's license, you have consented to reasonable measures to keep the road safe. Although this may sound somewhat like hooey (doesn't everybody have to drive?) the Supreme Court permits it under the constitution. As such, although you do have the right to decline a sobriety test, you'll be punished for doing so. A "no-blow" can result in you license being suspended for up to a year, along with a stint in jail. As such, while it's best to not answer an officer's questions in the field, and smart not to subject yourself to field sobriety tests, and you should definitely call a Denver criminal defense lawyer as soon as you think you might be in trouble for a DUI, one thing you probably won't be able to ultimately avoid is taking some kind of blood alcohol test. I will have more commentary on this in a later post, but for now just know that a Denver DUI lawyer can help make sure the blood alcohol test does as little damage to your case as possible, while protecting your rights throughout the process, so call one as soon as possible.
Wednesday, June 8, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / hourly or flat fees?
For many people who make mistakes and end up in a spot of trouble with the law, the cost of their Denver criminal defense lawyer is paramount. But just as crucial as the cost of the lawyer you hire can be how you are billed. Most attorneys bill an hourly rate: they take a retainer, bill their hours against that retainer until the case is over or until the retainer is gone, then ask for additional retainer money. If the client is unable to provide more money, the attorney will no longer represent him.
However, with Denver criminal defense lawyers, you typically have a choice of paying either hourly or something called a "graduated fixed fee." Essentially, a graduated fixed fee is a flat fee. However, Denver criminal defense lawyers are prohibited from charging a fee for the whole case then keeping the fee if they must drop the case for whatever reason. As such, the lawyer divides the case into parts, and assigns each part of the case a designated portion of the fee. He can then take the money as he earns it, although typically the case is seen through to its completion so the client is billed the entire amount.
What are the downsides of the fixed fee arrangement for the client? For one, it can carry significant sticker shock. Additionally, the client will typically have to foot the bill for the costs of the entire case right up front, unless the attorney will make a fee arrangement.
That said, there are significant upsides to the fixed fee. First, it ensures you will actually be able to afford the service you are paying for. If a Denver DUI attorney gives an hourly rate, then says it will take approximately 10 hours to represent you in the DUI and asks for that as a retainer, you have no assurances that the case will be resolved. He may burn through that entire retainer, due to unanticipated complications or other issues, and leave you trying to decide what to do: pony up more money or find another lawyer.
Second, a flat fee can ease significant burdens about your strategic decisions. If your Denver criminal defense attorney is working by the hour, he may say: this motion has a 40% chance of winning, and if you win, it will win the whole case. But it will take me another $2,000 worth of time to prepare the argument. In a flat fee situation, you have already covered this. The lawyer is bearing the risk of the case being more expensive than anticipated. That's why I use fixed fees: so you don't have to make hard decisions about your case.
However, with Denver criminal defense lawyers, you typically have a choice of paying either hourly or something called a "graduated fixed fee." Essentially, a graduated fixed fee is a flat fee. However, Denver criminal defense lawyers are prohibited from charging a fee for the whole case then keeping the fee if they must drop the case for whatever reason. As such, the lawyer divides the case into parts, and assigns each part of the case a designated portion of the fee. He can then take the money as he earns it, although typically the case is seen through to its completion so the client is billed the entire amount.
What are the downsides of the fixed fee arrangement for the client? For one, it can carry significant sticker shock. Additionally, the client will typically have to foot the bill for the costs of the entire case right up front, unless the attorney will make a fee arrangement.
That said, there are significant upsides to the fixed fee. First, it ensures you will actually be able to afford the service you are paying for. If a Denver DUI attorney gives an hourly rate, then says it will take approximately 10 hours to represent you in the DUI and asks for that as a retainer, you have no assurances that the case will be resolved. He may burn through that entire retainer, due to unanticipated complications or other issues, and leave you trying to decide what to do: pony up more money or find another lawyer.
Second, a flat fee can ease significant burdens about your strategic decisions. If your Denver criminal defense attorney is working by the hour, he may say: this motion has a 40% chance of winning, and if you win, it will win the whole case. But it will take me another $2,000 worth of time to prepare the argument. In a flat fee situation, you have already covered this. The lawyer is bearing the risk of the case being more expensive than anticipated. That's why I use fixed fees: so you don't have to make hard decisions about your case.
Monday, June 6, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / why many similar crimes receive different sentences
As a Denver criminal defense lawyer, one question I am frequently asked is why it is so hard to predict the outcome of cases? After all, there are thousands of DUIs every year, and hundreds of assault cases, so why can't a Denver DUI lawyer have a fairly firm idea as to what the sentence is likely to be? The answer to this question boils down to a few essential factors.
First, every case is different. Where a client sees a basic DUI case, a Denver DUI lawyer sees many different factors that can affect the outcome. What evidence will be admissible in court? How much did the defendant tell the arresting officer? Is it a first offense or a fifth offense? What kind of mitigating evidence can be presented to minimize the sentence, or make the defendant look better for the jury?
Second, each jurisdiction treats cases differently. Where some counties are extremely busy with murders and gang violence, with little time to take DUIs to trial, others see DUIs or drug crimes as a top priority. If you're unlucky enough to get charged in one of these harsher jurisdictions, sometimes there is basically no room for bargaining. The prosecutor makes an offer, and the defendant can either take it or go to trial.
In a more lenient jurisdiction, the prosecutors will be more reluctant to bear the time and monetary costs of trial. That means more room for bargaining, and a better chance of a decent plea bargain even without winning at trial. Ultimately, the outcome of a case depends on a variety of factors. If your Denver DUI lawyer makes any concrete promises, run away, since even the best criminal defense lawyer cannot make any guarantees, with so many different factors affecting the potential outcome, many outside the lawyer's control.
First, every case is different. Where a client sees a basic DUI case, a Denver DUI lawyer sees many different factors that can affect the outcome. What evidence will be admissible in court? How much did the defendant tell the arresting officer? Is it a first offense or a fifth offense? What kind of mitigating evidence can be presented to minimize the sentence, or make the defendant look better for the jury?
Second, each jurisdiction treats cases differently. Where some counties are extremely busy with murders and gang violence, with little time to take DUIs to trial, others see DUIs or drug crimes as a top priority. If you're unlucky enough to get charged in one of these harsher jurisdictions, sometimes there is basically no room for bargaining. The prosecutor makes an offer, and the defendant can either take it or go to trial.
In a more lenient jurisdiction, the prosecutors will be more reluctant to bear the time and monetary costs of trial. That means more room for bargaining, and a better chance of a decent plea bargain even without winning at trial. Ultimately, the outcome of a case depends on a variety of factors. If your Denver DUI lawyer makes any concrete promises, run away, since even the best criminal defense lawyer cannot make any guarantees, with so many different factors affecting the potential outcome, many outside the lawyer's control.
Tuesday, May 31, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / speeding tickets in the mail
Since I'm a Denver criminal defense lawyer, you may be shocked to find that I occasionally disobey traffic laws. The other day, I got an $80 speeding ticket in the mail! Of course, it was from several weeks ago, so I had no recollection of going 31 in a school zone. But there was my picture of me in my car, and a close-up of my license plate. What are you supposed to do when you get a Denver traffic citation in the mail without being pulled over? Should you call a Denver criminal defense lawyer, or simply remit payment and be done with it?
Unfortunately, the system is really designed just to separate you from your money, not to actually fight the ticket. The punishment ($80) is just enough to be a pain in the neck, but since it's not reported to DMV and doesn't count towards license suspensions, it's probably not worth fighting. Even the most efficient Denver traffic ticket lawyer won't be able to fight this kind of ticket for less than $50. So even if you do win, the only savings you're looking at is $30. If you lose, you'll still have to pay the lawyer, then the ticket, then a court assessment. Going it on your own will save you the attorney's fee, but at the cost of your own time. You'll have to go to the Denver City and County Building twice: first to set a court date with the Clerk, then to actually go to Court. Depending on how busy court is that day, you'll also have to wait in line for a significant period of time before getting to state your case. And there's no guarantee you'll win the case. So if you get a speeding ticket in the mail from one of the mobile police units, my advice is to save yourself the time and hassle and just pay it online. And be thankful you didn't get pulled over--that's a $200+ ticket in addition to points which count toward license suspensions, and the possibility of increased insurance premiums.
Unfortunately, the system is really designed just to separate you from your money, not to actually fight the ticket. The punishment ($80) is just enough to be a pain in the neck, but since it's not reported to DMV and doesn't count towards license suspensions, it's probably not worth fighting. Even the most efficient Denver traffic ticket lawyer won't be able to fight this kind of ticket for less than $50. So even if you do win, the only savings you're looking at is $30. If you lose, you'll still have to pay the lawyer, then the ticket, then a court assessment. Going it on your own will save you the attorney's fee, but at the cost of your own time. You'll have to go to the Denver City and County Building twice: first to set a court date with the Clerk, then to actually go to Court. Depending on how busy court is that day, you'll also have to wait in line for a significant period of time before getting to state your case. And there's no guarantee you'll win the case. So if you get a speeding ticket in the mail from one of the mobile police units, my advice is to save yourself the time and hassle and just pay it online. And be thankful you didn't get pulled over--that's a $200+ ticket in addition to points which count toward license suspensions, and the possibility of increased insurance premiums.
Friday, May 27, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer/judge or jury trial?
As a Denver criminal defense lawyer, a common issue clients raise is whether it is better to have their case heard before a judge or jury. The right to have the case heard before a jury of peers is every defendant's right under the Sixth Amendment. Although six person juries are allowed by the Supreme Court, and not every state requires unanimous juries, in the State of Colorado, you have the right to a 12 person jury and a unanimous finding of guilt. Although only your Denver criminal defense lawyer can make a recommendation on the facts of your case, and every case is different, here are a few pros and cons of both the judge and jury options.
The benefit of trying your case to a jury is nearly exclusively in the fact that it is harder to persuade 12 people than it is to persuade a single judge. Although there are plenty of movies where defense attorneys mislead unsuspecting juries or use specious arguments to win them over, this is relatively rare in the real world. Most juries conscientiously attempt to correctly apply the facts to the law as the judge gives it to them. However, it's still hard to convince 12 people of something beyond a reasonable doubt. As such, most defense attorneys will advise their clients to exercise the right to a jury trial.
The benefit of going to a judge is only in circumstances where a jury is likely to be unable to remain impartial. In certain cases, the fact-finder will be asked to consider evidence in a highly sensitive way--disregard possibly incriminating evidence for the purpose of determining guilt but use it for something else. In that case, a jury may not be reliable, and your Denver criminal defense lawyer may recommend not going to a jury and instead trying the case in a bench trial: in front of a judge alone.
The benefit of trying your case to a jury is nearly exclusively in the fact that it is harder to persuade 12 people than it is to persuade a single judge. Although there are plenty of movies where defense attorneys mislead unsuspecting juries or use specious arguments to win them over, this is relatively rare in the real world. Most juries conscientiously attempt to correctly apply the facts to the law as the judge gives it to them. However, it's still hard to convince 12 people of something beyond a reasonable doubt. As such, most defense attorneys will advise their clients to exercise the right to a jury trial.
The benefit of going to a judge is only in circumstances where a jury is likely to be unable to remain impartial. In certain cases, the fact-finder will be asked to consider evidence in a highly sensitive way--disregard possibly incriminating evidence for the purpose of determining guilt but use it for something else. In that case, a jury may not be reliable, and your Denver criminal defense lawyer may recommend not going to a jury and instead trying the case in a bench trial: in front of a judge alone.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)