There are a lot of attorneys who do not care for fictional accounts of our profession. This Denver criminal defense lawyer is not one of them. I thoroughly enjoy Law & Order, John Grisham books, whatever, so long as it's done right. The courtroom still has some amount of romance for sure. One thing that is noticeable over the course of maybe my dad's lifetime, however, is that there are less and less criminal defense lawyers who take their place as the hero in these fictional accounts. Back in the day, a criminal defense lawyer could look on television or in the movies and books and see guys like Clarence Darrow, Atticus Finch, and Perry Mason taking on the man. These days, our lawyer heroes include Jack McCoy (the hard-boiled tough guy prosecutor from Law & Order), the JAG folks (who both prosecute and defend to be fair) and so on. It's a pretty sad state of affairs when the best defense lawyer character that immediately springs to mind is either Matthew McConaghy in the Lincoln Lawyer or Matthew McConaghy in A Time to Kill.
Obviously, to some extent this is just market research and desire not to be similar to anything that's come before. Nobody's going to make a heroic defense more awesome or more complex than Atticus Finch or the guy from Anatomy of a Murder. Of course, party of that is that there are too many Matthew McConaghys and not enough Gregory Pecks anymore. But does the lack of prevalance of heroic defense attorneys sort of symbolize our movement as a society towards a "tough on crime" stance? Probably. In the 1960s, people were very concerned about the power of the government and "the man." Defense lawyers became heroes who sort of spearheaded the fight against this. In the 80s and 90s, folks were very concerned about crime, which is when Law & Order and all those cop shows rose to prominence. With crime trending downward for the past 20 years, hopefully we will see a correction toward a more balanced view of the criminal justice system.
Showing posts with label criminal defense attorney. Show all posts
Showing posts with label criminal defense attorney. Show all posts
Wednesday, August 17, 2011
Monday, August 1, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / bail bondsmen are not chumps
I have pretty strong reservations about the role of bail bondsmen in the American legal system. My problem comes down to them being the only part of the law enforcement system that operates for a profit. Sure, defense lawyers make a profit, but we're fighting against the state. The bail bondsmen are there to ensure that the defendant comes to court, and they get paid for it even if the client is innocent, at the client's expense, not the state's. I've voiced these concerns about bail bondsmen before.
Still, I recognize that bail bondsmen will be a fact of life for Denver criminal defense lawyers and their clients for the foreseeable future, seeing as the surety system is in place in 47 states. Not everybody can make bail in Colorado or other states, and giving up 10% is better than staying in jail. So the current system is something we as Denver criminal defense lawyers have to deal with an understand.
In that vein, there is an interesting special in the New York Times interactive section (warning, it's a video/slideshow), about bail bondsmen. Basically the piece shows they have the most interesting job in the world, dabbling in about a million different fields that most Americans would think you need a lifetime of training to figure out.
First, as an insurance man, a bail bondsman must evaluate the risk of flight for every client. Then, to ensure he gets paid, the bail bondsman has to evaluate the value of collateral the client puts up to ensure his appearance. Then, a bail bondsman also acts as a bounty hunter for those who don't show up to court. All this stuff happens in a wild-west atmosphere with hardly any government regulation, so the guy is on his own. The lesson I took away from the piece as a Denver criminal defense lawyer was that you don't want to mess with bail bondsmen. They are incredibly resourceful, smart, and basically have freedom of the country to do whatever it takes to get defendants into court.
Still, I recognize that bail bondsmen will be a fact of life for Denver criminal defense lawyers and their clients for the foreseeable future, seeing as the surety system is in place in 47 states. Not everybody can make bail in Colorado or other states, and giving up 10% is better than staying in jail. So the current system is something we as Denver criminal defense lawyers have to deal with an understand.
In that vein, there is an interesting special in the New York Times interactive section (warning, it's a video/slideshow), about bail bondsmen. Basically the piece shows they have the most interesting job in the world, dabbling in about a million different fields that most Americans would think you need a lifetime of training to figure out.
First, as an insurance man, a bail bondsman must evaluate the risk of flight for every client. Then, to ensure he gets paid, the bail bondsman has to evaluate the value of collateral the client puts up to ensure his appearance. Then, a bail bondsman also acts as a bounty hunter for those who don't show up to court. All this stuff happens in a wild-west atmosphere with hardly any government regulation, so the guy is on his own. The lesson I took away from the piece as a Denver criminal defense lawyer was that you don't want to mess with bail bondsmen. They are incredibly resourceful, smart, and basically have freedom of the country to do whatever it takes to get defendants into court.
Friday, July 22, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / reasonable doubt
With the prominence of the Casey Anthony "trial of the century" action, reasonable doubt as a reason to acquit a defendant has been sort of current. Regardless of the news though, I think reasonable doubt remains one of the least understood, yet most powerful, tools at the disposal of attorneys. That's frankly probably because it is not very well defined.
Ask ten different Denver criminal defense attorneys, judges or prosecutors, and you will probably get ten different responses as to what reasonable doubt actually is. There are about a hundred different definitions that can be read to the jury and have been approved under the United States constitution by the Supreme Court. However, only two things are really known about it for certain: it's the highest level of proof required in the American justice system (higher than "some evidence" (yes this is an actual standard), a preponderance (a majority), and clear and convincing evidence. Of course, this hierarchy is of little help since the courts steadfastly refuse to assign numerical probabilities to any of the standards, except for a preponderance, which is simply 50.00001% either way.
In lieu of anything actually concrete or helpful, the courts have devised a variety of explanations they can tell the jury. One is to say it's the level of confidence you use in your closest and most important private affairs. This strikes me as a good instruction for a Denver criminal defense lawyer to seek out. Drawing a comparison to the juror's personal affairs is a good way to bring out the uncertainties in the case. If the prosecution's primary witness has a lengthy criminal record, the attorney can point to that and say: would you trust this man in your most important personal affairs? With your money? To babysit your kids? While that kind of personal appeal to the jurors may seem below board, it is important to make sure the jurors understand the gravity of the situation, and understand just how hefty a burden the prosecution must bear to put a fellow citizen in prison.
Although there are a number of other explanations the court can give the jury as to what reasonable doubt is, frequently they just leave it to the jury to figure it out. In that case, the lawyers have very little to work with, except to sort of explain what they think reasonable doubt should mean in the particular case, and why it's the best definition. In that case, there will be no clean resolution except the jury's verdict.
Stay tuned to the Denver criminal defense lawyer blog where next I will be taking on burdens of proof as related to circumstantial evidence.
Ask ten different Denver criminal defense attorneys, judges or prosecutors, and you will probably get ten different responses as to what reasonable doubt actually is. There are about a hundred different definitions that can be read to the jury and have been approved under the United States constitution by the Supreme Court. However, only two things are really known about it for certain: it's the highest level of proof required in the American justice system (higher than "some evidence" (yes this is an actual standard), a preponderance (a majority), and clear and convincing evidence. Of course, this hierarchy is of little help since the courts steadfastly refuse to assign numerical probabilities to any of the standards, except for a preponderance, which is simply 50.00001% either way.
In lieu of anything actually concrete or helpful, the courts have devised a variety of explanations they can tell the jury. One is to say it's the level of confidence you use in your closest and most important private affairs. This strikes me as a good instruction for a Denver criminal defense lawyer to seek out. Drawing a comparison to the juror's personal affairs is a good way to bring out the uncertainties in the case. If the prosecution's primary witness has a lengthy criminal record, the attorney can point to that and say: would you trust this man in your most important personal affairs? With your money? To babysit your kids? While that kind of personal appeal to the jurors may seem below board, it is important to make sure the jurors understand the gravity of the situation, and understand just how hefty a burden the prosecution must bear to put a fellow citizen in prison.
Although there are a number of other explanations the court can give the jury as to what reasonable doubt is, frequently they just leave it to the jury to figure it out. In that case, the lawyers have very little to work with, except to sort of explain what they think reasonable doubt should mean in the particular case, and why it's the best definition. In that case, there will be no clean resolution except the jury's verdict.
Stay tuned to the Denver criminal defense lawyer blog where next I will be taking on burdens of proof as related to circumstantial evidence.
Thursday, July 21, 2011
Denver criminal lawyer / the role of the Supreme Court
On the Denver criminal defense lawyer blog, I've been talking quite a bit about appeals. As you may have noticed, a lot of appeals end up with a failed petition to the Colorado Supreme Court and the U.S. Supreme Court. In most cases, the Supreme Court won't even hear the case. So what's it even for?
Basically the Supreme Court is more of a political institution than a court. Although the common law evolved out of hundreds of cases being heard, decided and recorded, and the Supreme Court is in the mold of a common law court, the number of cases in the entire United States makes it impossible for them to hear even a fraction of them. So they basically just pick the politically important ones--ones where the court wants to change the law in some significant way and where the facts fit their idea of a good case to change course. In fact, if you do get heard by the U.S. Supreme Court after losing at the circuit or State Supreme Court level, there's a good chance you'll win: a known saying among Denver criminal defense lawyers is that the Supreme Court hears cases to overturn them, not to affirm.
However the fraction of cases, and specifically the fraction of criminal law cases, pales to the number of cases in the United States. There are hundreds of thousands of criminal cases in U.S. state and federal courts. The Supreme Court only hears a little over one hundred each year. Of those, many are from maritime law (over which the Supreme Court has significant jurisdiction). Others are cases where states are suing other states, federal civil cases, and cases where an executive officer is charged. That means probably less than 20 criminal cases make it all the way to Washington each year. And some of those are federal! So the chances of a regular old Denver criminal defense lawyer and his client getting a day in front of the nation's high court are pretty much nothing. Because the Supreme Court is a political body and really hears cases to help in governing the country and interpreting the constitution, not to correct errors in state courts.
Basically the Supreme Court is more of a political institution than a court. Although the common law evolved out of hundreds of cases being heard, decided and recorded, and the Supreme Court is in the mold of a common law court, the number of cases in the entire United States makes it impossible for them to hear even a fraction of them. So they basically just pick the politically important ones--ones where the court wants to change the law in some significant way and where the facts fit their idea of a good case to change course. In fact, if you do get heard by the U.S. Supreme Court after losing at the circuit or State Supreme Court level, there's a good chance you'll win: a known saying among Denver criminal defense lawyers is that the Supreme Court hears cases to overturn them, not to affirm.
However the fraction of cases, and specifically the fraction of criminal law cases, pales to the number of cases in the United States. There are hundreds of thousands of criminal cases in U.S. state and federal courts. The Supreme Court only hears a little over one hundred each year. Of those, many are from maritime law (over which the Supreme Court has significant jurisdiction). Others are cases where states are suing other states, federal civil cases, and cases where an executive officer is charged. That means probably less than 20 criminal cases make it all the way to Washington each year. And some of those are federal! So the chances of a regular old Denver criminal defense lawyer and his client getting a day in front of the nation's high court are pretty much nothing. Because the Supreme Court is a political body and really hears cases to help in governing the country and interpreting the constitution, not to correct errors in state courts.
Friday, July 15, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / what is post-conviction relief?
As a Denver criminal defense lawyer, one question I hear a lot is what sort of options a person has after being convicted of a crime. Although the vast majority of those who are convicted of crimes will end of just serving out their sentence and being released, paroled, or fined, the State of Colorado does offer a few options for those who want to challenge their convictions to the end. The first option is direct appeal, which I will talk about in a later post. After defeat on direct appeal, the convicted person may bring an action in Colorado District Court for post-conviction relief. Generally, this action will cover anything that he was not able to raise on appeal, including violations of rights under the Colorado and United States Constitutions. Post-conviction actions take two main forms.
By far the most common form of post-conviction relief action is a suit claiming the original Denver criminal defense lawyer performed ineffectively. Many times the trial attorney can make it impossible to properly appeal a case because he didn't object on the record. That means the Court of Appeals can't review that potential mistake by the trial court. Or it's also possible the Denver criminal defense lawyer didn't do a good job investigating the case. The standard in these cases is that the lawyer's conduct must fall below a reasonable standard of professional conduct. If the attorney had limited resources and made a reasonable decision on what to investigate, the court won't grant relief. Additionally, the defendant must prove at post-conviction that absent the attorney's mistake, there would have been a reasonable probability of a not-guilty verdict. So if the potentially beneficial avenue of investigation would not have changed the outcome, no relief is available.
The other common form of post-conviction relief action is against the prosecutor for misconduct. Generally this relates to evidence that was not disclosed during the discovery phase of the investigation. Since non-disclosure of relevant evidence is very serious, the burden here isn't quite as high. However, it also doesn't happen very much. Prosecutors know their convictions can be thrown out if they don't disclose, so they are scrupulous.
Next post will be about direct appeals. Stay tuned.
By far the most common form of post-conviction relief action is a suit claiming the original Denver criminal defense lawyer performed ineffectively. Many times the trial attorney can make it impossible to properly appeal a case because he didn't object on the record. That means the Court of Appeals can't review that potential mistake by the trial court. Or it's also possible the Denver criminal defense lawyer didn't do a good job investigating the case. The standard in these cases is that the lawyer's conduct must fall below a reasonable standard of professional conduct. If the attorney had limited resources and made a reasonable decision on what to investigate, the court won't grant relief. Additionally, the defendant must prove at post-conviction that absent the attorney's mistake, there would have been a reasonable probability of a not-guilty verdict. So if the potentially beneficial avenue of investigation would not have changed the outcome, no relief is available.
The other common form of post-conviction relief action is against the prosecutor for misconduct. Generally this relates to evidence that was not disclosed during the discovery phase of the investigation. Since non-disclosure of relevant evidence is very serious, the burden here isn't quite as high. However, it also doesn't happen very much. Prosecutors know their convictions can be thrown out if they don't disclose, so they are scrupulous.
Next post will be about direct appeals. Stay tuned.
Wednesday, June 8, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / hourly or flat fees?
For many people who make mistakes and end up in a spot of trouble with the law, the cost of their Denver criminal defense lawyer is paramount. But just as crucial as the cost of the lawyer you hire can be how you are billed. Most attorneys bill an hourly rate: they take a retainer, bill their hours against that retainer until the case is over or until the retainer is gone, then ask for additional retainer money. If the client is unable to provide more money, the attorney will no longer represent him.
However, with Denver criminal defense lawyers, you typically have a choice of paying either hourly or something called a "graduated fixed fee." Essentially, a graduated fixed fee is a flat fee. However, Denver criminal defense lawyers are prohibited from charging a fee for the whole case then keeping the fee if they must drop the case for whatever reason. As such, the lawyer divides the case into parts, and assigns each part of the case a designated portion of the fee. He can then take the money as he earns it, although typically the case is seen through to its completion so the client is billed the entire amount.
What are the downsides of the fixed fee arrangement for the client? For one, it can carry significant sticker shock. Additionally, the client will typically have to foot the bill for the costs of the entire case right up front, unless the attorney will make a fee arrangement.
That said, there are significant upsides to the fixed fee. First, it ensures you will actually be able to afford the service you are paying for. If a Denver DUI attorney gives an hourly rate, then says it will take approximately 10 hours to represent you in the DUI and asks for that as a retainer, you have no assurances that the case will be resolved. He may burn through that entire retainer, due to unanticipated complications or other issues, and leave you trying to decide what to do: pony up more money or find another lawyer.
Second, a flat fee can ease significant burdens about your strategic decisions. If your Denver criminal defense attorney is working by the hour, he may say: this motion has a 40% chance of winning, and if you win, it will win the whole case. But it will take me another $2,000 worth of time to prepare the argument. In a flat fee situation, you have already covered this. The lawyer is bearing the risk of the case being more expensive than anticipated. That's why I use fixed fees: so you don't have to make hard decisions about your case.
However, with Denver criminal defense lawyers, you typically have a choice of paying either hourly or something called a "graduated fixed fee." Essentially, a graduated fixed fee is a flat fee. However, Denver criminal defense lawyers are prohibited from charging a fee for the whole case then keeping the fee if they must drop the case for whatever reason. As such, the lawyer divides the case into parts, and assigns each part of the case a designated portion of the fee. He can then take the money as he earns it, although typically the case is seen through to its completion so the client is billed the entire amount.
What are the downsides of the fixed fee arrangement for the client? For one, it can carry significant sticker shock. Additionally, the client will typically have to foot the bill for the costs of the entire case right up front, unless the attorney will make a fee arrangement.
That said, there are significant upsides to the fixed fee. First, it ensures you will actually be able to afford the service you are paying for. If a Denver DUI attorney gives an hourly rate, then says it will take approximately 10 hours to represent you in the DUI and asks for that as a retainer, you have no assurances that the case will be resolved. He may burn through that entire retainer, due to unanticipated complications or other issues, and leave you trying to decide what to do: pony up more money or find another lawyer.
Second, a flat fee can ease significant burdens about your strategic decisions. If your Denver criminal defense attorney is working by the hour, he may say: this motion has a 40% chance of winning, and if you win, it will win the whole case. But it will take me another $2,000 worth of time to prepare the argument. In a flat fee situation, you have already covered this. The lawyer is bearing the risk of the case being more expensive than anticipated. That's why I use fixed fees: so you don't have to make hard decisions about your case.
Friday, May 27, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer/judge or jury trial?
As a Denver criminal defense lawyer, a common issue clients raise is whether it is better to have their case heard before a judge or jury. The right to have the case heard before a jury of peers is every defendant's right under the Sixth Amendment. Although six person juries are allowed by the Supreme Court, and not every state requires unanimous juries, in the State of Colorado, you have the right to a 12 person jury and a unanimous finding of guilt. Although only your Denver criminal defense lawyer can make a recommendation on the facts of your case, and every case is different, here are a few pros and cons of both the judge and jury options.
The benefit of trying your case to a jury is nearly exclusively in the fact that it is harder to persuade 12 people than it is to persuade a single judge. Although there are plenty of movies where defense attorneys mislead unsuspecting juries or use specious arguments to win them over, this is relatively rare in the real world. Most juries conscientiously attempt to correctly apply the facts to the law as the judge gives it to them. However, it's still hard to convince 12 people of something beyond a reasonable doubt. As such, most defense attorneys will advise their clients to exercise the right to a jury trial.
The benefit of going to a judge is only in circumstances where a jury is likely to be unable to remain impartial. In certain cases, the fact-finder will be asked to consider evidence in a highly sensitive way--disregard possibly incriminating evidence for the purpose of determining guilt but use it for something else. In that case, a jury may not be reliable, and your Denver criminal defense lawyer may recommend not going to a jury and instead trying the case in a bench trial: in front of a judge alone.
The benefit of trying your case to a jury is nearly exclusively in the fact that it is harder to persuade 12 people than it is to persuade a single judge. Although there are plenty of movies where defense attorneys mislead unsuspecting juries or use specious arguments to win them over, this is relatively rare in the real world. Most juries conscientiously attempt to correctly apply the facts to the law as the judge gives it to them. However, it's still hard to convince 12 people of something beyond a reasonable doubt. As such, most defense attorneys will advise their clients to exercise the right to a jury trial.
The benefit of going to a judge is only in circumstances where a jury is likely to be unable to remain impartial. In certain cases, the fact-finder will be asked to consider evidence in a highly sensitive way--disregard possibly incriminating evidence for the purpose of determining guilt but use it for something else. In that case, a jury may not be reliable, and your Denver criminal defense lawyer may recommend not going to a jury and instead trying the case in a bench trial: in front of a judge alone.
Monday, May 23, 2011
Colorado criminal defense attorney/think before you plead
If you are charged with a crime and haven't hired a Colorado criminal defense attorney yet, the prosecution is probably telling you about all the benefits of simply pleading guilty and getting it over with. This can sound appealing for several reasons. First, hiring a Denver criminal defense attorney might seem like a stretch on your budget. Second, maybe you are factually guilty and don't think you would stand a chance at contesting the charges. Third, perhaps the time it will take to fight your charges.
These concerns are normal, and unfortunately these are the costs and risks of going through the process. I'll look at the three concerns one at a time. First, the cost of a Colorado criminal defense attorney is fairly minor in comparison to the potential costs of too hasty a plea. In addition to the fines and costs you'll incur as a penalty for the plea, there is also the potentially permanent criminal record. This can make it difficult to find a job, find an apartment to rent, and get credit. A Denver criminal defense attorney can craft the plea such that expungement is easiest, if you follow certain steps after conviction. These issues apply to the concern that you don't have time to fight it: the cost of making the wrong plea may be astronomical--the cost of your time may seem like a huge imposition but is probably saving you time and money in the long run.
Second, it doesn't really matter at the initial stage whether you are factually guilty or not. The initial phase of the process is simply a feeling-out process. The very first offer from the prosecution is generally very close to what you would get for going to trial and being convicted--they aren't actually offering anything. Once your defense attorney has had a chance to dig into the prosecution's case and assess its strengths and weaknesses, you will get a much more fair offer.
These concerns are normal, and unfortunately these are the costs and risks of going through the process. I'll look at the three concerns one at a time. First, the cost of a Colorado criminal defense attorney is fairly minor in comparison to the potential costs of too hasty a plea. In addition to the fines and costs you'll incur as a penalty for the plea, there is also the potentially permanent criminal record. This can make it difficult to find a job, find an apartment to rent, and get credit. A Denver criminal defense attorney can craft the plea such that expungement is easiest, if you follow certain steps after conviction. These issues apply to the concern that you don't have time to fight it: the cost of making the wrong plea may be astronomical--the cost of your time may seem like a huge imposition but is probably saving you time and money in the long run.
Second, it doesn't really matter at the initial stage whether you are factually guilty or not. The initial phase of the process is simply a feeling-out process. The very first offer from the prosecution is generally very close to what you would get for going to trial and being convicted--they aren't actually offering anything. Once your defense attorney has had a chance to dig into the prosecution's case and assess its strengths and weaknesses, you will get a much more fair offer.
Wednesday, May 4, 2011
Colorado criminal defense attorney/Right to an attorney
Everybody knows from Law and Order that the police read defendants their Miranda rights after they arrest them. However, since these readings basically seem like rote ceremony, most people that aren't Denver criminal defense lawyers are unaware of how these rights work and how to invoke them. Basically, the Miranda warnings were implemented so the police could not force confessions out of tired, intimidated subjects who didn't know their constitutional rights and didn't have an attorney present. The most crucial component of protecting yourself is your right to an attorney.
Although the Miranda reading is theoretically designed to inform the suspect of his rights, there is really no way somebody with no experience in the legal system would glean the information he needs to make an informed decision about waiver. The officer need not even verbally ask if the suspect wants to waive his rights. The suspect merely needs to know that signing the card indicates a waiver. As such, the suspect may be left with the strong impression that he really has no choice but to sign the card, or that that is what a prudent suspect should do.
Most importantly, a suspect is given no real idea how to end the interrogation. If he equivocates, openly wonders whether it's a good idea to talk to the police, or even tentatively says he probably shouldn't speak to them, that is not treated as an invocation of the right to remain silent. Law enforcement can continue to attempt to persuade him through all these signs that he probably doesn't want to talk. The crucial and magic words are "I want a lawyer." It doesn't matter which criminal defense attorney you ask for, or if you even know one. The interrogation must stop until an attorney shows up. So know this the next time law enforcement gives you trouble: ask for an attorney and they have to stop asking questions. It's the constitution.
Although the Miranda reading is theoretically designed to inform the suspect of his rights, there is really no way somebody with no experience in the legal system would glean the information he needs to make an informed decision about waiver. The officer need not even verbally ask if the suspect wants to waive his rights. The suspect merely needs to know that signing the card indicates a waiver. As such, the suspect may be left with the strong impression that he really has no choice but to sign the card, or that that is what a prudent suspect should do.
Most importantly, a suspect is given no real idea how to end the interrogation. If he equivocates, openly wonders whether it's a good idea to talk to the police, or even tentatively says he probably shouldn't speak to them, that is not treated as an invocation of the right to remain silent. Law enforcement can continue to attempt to persuade him through all these signs that he probably doesn't want to talk. The crucial and magic words are "I want a lawyer." It doesn't matter which criminal defense attorney you ask for, or if you even know one. The interrogation must stop until an attorney shows up. So know this the next time law enforcement gives you trouble: ask for an attorney and they have to stop asking questions. It's the constitution.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)