On the Denver criminal defense lawyer blog, I've been talking quite a bit about appeals. As you may have noticed, a lot of appeals end up with a failed petition to the Colorado Supreme Court and the U.S. Supreme Court. In most cases, the Supreme Court won't even hear the case. So what's it even for?
Basically the Supreme Court is more of a political institution than a court. Although the common law evolved out of hundreds of cases being heard, decided and recorded, and the Supreme Court is in the mold of a common law court, the number of cases in the entire United States makes it impossible for them to hear even a fraction of them. So they basically just pick the politically important ones--ones where the court wants to change the law in some significant way and where the facts fit their idea of a good case to change course. In fact, if you do get heard by the U.S. Supreme Court after losing at the circuit or State Supreme Court level, there's a good chance you'll win: a known saying among Denver criminal defense lawyers is that the Supreme Court hears cases to overturn them, not to affirm.
However the fraction of cases, and specifically the fraction of criminal law cases, pales to the number of cases in the United States. There are hundreds of thousands of criminal cases in U.S. state and federal courts. The Supreme Court only hears a little over one hundred each year. Of those, many are from maritime law (over which the Supreme Court has significant jurisdiction). Others are cases where states are suing other states, federal civil cases, and cases where an executive officer is charged. That means probably less than 20 criminal cases make it all the way to Washington each year. And some of those are federal! So the chances of a regular old Denver criminal defense lawyer and his client getting a day in front of the nation's high court are pretty much nothing. Because the Supreme Court is a political body and really hears cases to help in governing the country and interpreting the constitution, not to correct errors in state courts.
Showing posts with label colorado appeals. Show all posts
Showing posts with label colorado appeals. Show all posts
Thursday, July 21, 2011
Tuesday, July 19, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / appealing to the Supreme Court
If the direct appeal is successful, typically the appellant (fancy word for convicted person who appealed his conviction), has a few remaining opportunities to attempt to have the conviction set aside. The first option is to petition the Colorado Supreme Court for review of the appellate court's dismissal. The defendant and his Denver criminal defense attorney can argue that the trial and appellate courts incorrectly applied the federal or state constitutions, or ignored Colorado statutes. However, the Supreme Court need not even hear the case in the first place. That's because only the initial appeal to the Court of Appeals is considered an "appeal of right." The remaining ones are a privilege. As such, the Colorado defense attorney charged with going to the Supreme Court can not skip straight to briefing the case. First, he must write a petition (a one or two page argument) telling the Colorado Supreme Court why it should even take briefs on the case. Generally the Court is looking to make a legal statement, not simply reverse the error. So the best lawyers will attempt to make an argument that the individual case represents a good opportunity for the Court to either change the law or make a statement. Of course, the odds of even having the case heard are extraordinarily slim.
However, if the court does decide to hear the case, then the real work begins. The briefing process described in the previous post happens all over again. Since the Court has already decided the case was important enough to hear, they are almost certain to have oral arguments, again as described in the post on direct appeals. If the Colorado Supreme Court does decide to hear the case, the chances of getting the appeals court's decision reversed are fairly good. However, this happens in a miniscule fraction of the cases. For all intents and purposes, the defendant should simply begin planning for the post-conviction relief process. But going through the formalities of the appeal to the Supreme Court is crucial for reasons I'll detail in the next post about habeas corpus.
After the petition to the State Supreme Court is (in all likelihood) turned down, the defendant has one last option: appeal to the United States Supreme Court. Appeals from the state supreme court do not go through the federal process with the district and circuit courts. That's because those courts only have jurisdiction over federal law cases and certain civil law cases. A petitioner from a state must go directly to the U.S. Supreme Court with an argument for why his constitutional rights were violated. Of course, this is exceedingly unlikely, since the Court hears only about 100 cases per year from the entire United States, including federal law cases, certain civil cases where people are from different states, and direct appeal cases. As I said, after the initial appeal, it is probably time to start planning for post-conviction relief.
However, if the court does decide to hear the case, then the real work begins. The briefing process described in the previous post happens all over again. Since the Court has already decided the case was important enough to hear, they are almost certain to have oral arguments, again as described in the post on direct appeals. If the Colorado Supreme Court does decide to hear the case, the chances of getting the appeals court's decision reversed are fairly good. However, this happens in a miniscule fraction of the cases. For all intents and purposes, the defendant should simply begin planning for the post-conviction relief process. But going through the formalities of the appeal to the Supreme Court is crucial for reasons I'll detail in the next post about habeas corpus.
After the petition to the State Supreme Court is (in all likelihood) turned down, the defendant has one last option: appeal to the United States Supreme Court. Appeals from the state supreme court do not go through the federal process with the district and circuit courts. That's because those courts only have jurisdiction over federal law cases and certain civil law cases. A petitioner from a state must go directly to the U.S. Supreme Court with an argument for why his constitutional rights were violated. Of course, this is exceedingly unlikely, since the Court hears only about 100 cases per year from the entire United States, including federal law cases, certain civil cases where people are from different states, and direct appeal cases. As I said, after the initial appeal, it is probably time to start planning for post-conviction relief.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)