The job for Denver criminal defense lawyers is frequently to show ambiguity and uncertainty in the facts. Today I'm going to talk about a case where uncertainty is really bad for defendants. Yesterday I talked about the consent exception to the exclusionary rule. I mentioned that consent is a crucial tool for the state. Using consent, they can avoid the burden of showing that a search was supported by a warrant and probable cause. Today I'm going to dig a bit deeper into consent, because it's just that important. Any Denver criminal defense lawyer will tell you that the nature of consent given by a defendant can make or break a case.
In general, it is people's natural reflex to be nice to police officers. That's good. There is no reason to piss off somebody who could seriously impact your fate during the potential criminal case against you. Despite all your constitutional rights, a cop who does not like you can really screw you over. However, where people struggle is finding the balance between being nice and protecting themselves. A person can be courteous and still be firm. And that's extremely important in the case of consent. The problem is that any sign of uncertainty can be taken as consent. If you say no, then OK, the court may rule you've given consent. If you've given consent in the first place, then try to revoke it, you may be out of luck. Basically, your Denver criminal defense lawyer will have a much easier time getting the evidence suppressed if you are very clear.
Also, if you make your wishes clear, you won't have to worry about going back and forth. If it appears you're unsure about letting the cops search you or your stuff, they'll keep trying to convince you. That just gives you more opportunities to say something wrong. Something that could get you in bigger trouble, or be used against you at trial. If you just say "no, you need a warrant" or "no, I want a lawyer," you're done. You get to call an attorney who will have dealt with something like this before. So be courteous, but firm in declining to consent to any searches of you or your belongings.
Showing posts with label implied consent. Show all posts
Showing posts with label implied consent. Show all posts
Monday, August 29, 2011
Sunday, August 28, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / the consent "exception"
Yesterday on the Denver criminal defense lawyer blog, I took a look at the exclusionary rule. The exclusionary rule says that if a cop does a search without a warrant and probable cause, the evidence can't be used against you in court. In that post, I mentioned that there are a lot of exceptions which mean the evidence can be used against you even if there is not a warrant and probable cause. I'm going to start with the exception that drives Denver criminal defense lawyers like me nuts: the consent exception.
Basically, the rule with consent is that if you consent to a search of your belongings, your Denver criminal defense lawyer can't come back later and suppress the evidence. This is a problem for defendants in a lot of cases, because cops are really good at getting you to consent. They'll tell you it'll go quicker if you let them have a look. They'll also imply that you don't really have a choice, they can do it the easy way or the hard way. That part is technically true, although if they do it the "hard way" you reserve your right to challenge the search later and possibly get crucial evidence thrown out of the case against you. Basically, the police will not be clear on the importance of waiving your fourth amendment rights. And make no mistake: when you consent to a search, you are waiving your fourth amendment rights.
Adding to this is a problem of basic human psychology. Many suspects think that only guilty people will invoke their rights, or refuse consent. They think if the cops hear "no," they will look more guilty, and things will go worse. However, if you've been pulled over, or stopped on the sidewalk or whatever, you already look pretty guilty in the eyes of law enforcement. Giving in to a request for a consent search isn't going to change that. It's just sacrificing one of your crucial weapons in the possible case against you down the road. Once you consent to the search, you are also telling the police that it's OK to bring anything they find into the case against you. A clear, vocal, renunciation of consent puts the burden of showing probable cause and possibly a warrant squarely on the shoulders of the prosecution. Do you really want to do the prosecutor's work for him?
Basically, the rule with consent is that if you consent to a search of your belongings, your Denver criminal defense lawyer can't come back later and suppress the evidence. This is a problem for defendants in a lot of cases, because cops are really good at getting you to consent. They'll tell you it'll go quicker if you let them have a look. They'll also imply that you don't really have a choice, they can do it the easy way or the hard way. That part is technically true, although if they do it the "hard way" you reserve your right to challenge the search later and possibly get crucial evidence thrown out of the case against you. Basically, the police will not be clear on the importance of waiving your fourth amendment rights. And make no mistake: when you consent to a search, you are waiving your fourth amendment rights.
Adding to this is a problem of basic human psychology. Many suspects think that only guilty people will invoke their rights, or refuse consent. They think if the cops hear "no," they will look more guilty, and things will go worse. However, if you've been pulled over, or stopped on the sidewalk or whatever, you already look pretty guilty in the eyes of law enforcement. Giving in to a request for a consent search isn't going to change that. It's just sacrificing one of your crucial weapons in the possible case against you down the road. Once you consent to the search, you are also telling the police that it's OK to bring anything they find into the case against you. A clear, vocal, renunciation of consent puts the burden of showing probable cause and possibly a warrant squarely on the shoulders of the prosecution. Do you really want to do the prosecutor's work for him?
Thursday, June 9, 2011
Denver criminal defense lawyer / what about a no blow?
Most Denver criminal defense attorneys will advise you not to cooperate with the police on the scene and instead ask for your Denver DUI lawyer immediately. That's because most of the things police officers will ask you to do, such as roadside sobriety tests and answering questions are totally optional. You don't have to do them, and it can't be used as evidence against you in court if you decline to cooperate. There is one exception: the blood alcohol test. Although the blood alcohol test is technically optional, if you decline to take it, the penalty is actually more severe than blowing an illegal level.
That's because of a doctrine called "implied consent." The theory goes that by possessing a driver's license, you have consented to reasonable measures to keep the road safe. Although this may sound somewhat like hooey (doesn't everybody have to drive?) the Supreme Court permits it under the constitution. As such, although you do have the right to decline a sobriety test, you'll be punished for doing so. A "no-blow" can result in you license being suspended for up to a year, along with a stint in jail. As such, while it's best to not answer an officer's questions in the field, and smart not to subject yourself to field sobriety tests, and you should definitely call a Denver criminal defense lawyer as soon as you think you might be in trouble for a DUI, one thing you probably won't be able to ultimately avoid is taking some kind of blood alcohol test. I will have more commentary on this in a later post, but for now just know that a Denver DUI lawyer can help make sure the blood alcohol test does as little damage to your case as possible, while protecting your rights throughout the process, so call one as soon as possible.
That's because of a doctrine called "implied consent." The theory goes that by possessing a driver's license, you have consented to reasonable measures to keep the road safe. Although this may sound somewhat like hooey (doesn't everybody have to drive?) the Supreme Court permits it under the constitution. As such, although you do have the right to decline a sobriety test, you'll be punished for doing so. A "no-blow" can result in you license being suspended for up to a year, along with a stint in jail. As such, while it's best to not answer an officer's questions in the field, and smart not to subject yourself to field sobriety tests, and you should definitely call a Denver criminal defense lawyer as soon as you think you might be in trouble for a DUI, one thing you probably won't be able to ultimately avoid is taking some kind of blood alcohol test. I will have more commentary on this in a later post, but for now just know that a Denver DUI lawyer can help make sure the blood alcohol test does as little damage to your case as possible, while protecting your rights throughout the process, so call one as soon as possible.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)